Who knows best: Ever since a local website here began running a series of on-line polls for readers to vote on the best this-or-that in town, tempers have been flaring. Oh, “Best Cheeseburger” went off smoothly enough, I suppose. But when it came time to award “Best Dry Cleaner,” things got touchier. “Why run these stupid surveys if you’re not going to include Sanda’s?” wrote in one partisan, who no doubt became even more irate when his place ended up coming in second after it was finally added to the list. (“If we’d only been given adequate ballot access!” I can hear him yelling at his computer as he scrolled through the final results.) Next came “Best Pre-School.” After the dust settled on that, half the parents in town weren’t speaking to each other.
So there’s been more heat than light. I sometimes wonder whether computer voting is even the right way to go about this sort of thing. Are there not enough real experts around (on dry cleaning, say) that a board of them can’t be assembled to bring some discipline to the process? The judges would sample every place in town and, free of the lingering resentment a layman might harbor over the odd cracked button years ago or mysterious bleach stain, objectively determine once and for all which is the town’s champ. Kind of like how they do it on Throwdown. At the very least, the people at Sanda’s must be itching for a rematch.
And who picks the categories? More to the point, what in the world are their priorities? Mrs. Banks and our older daughter spent last week in Florida visiting my mother (don’t ask), which meant my son and I went out for dinner every night. In a situation like that it can be useful, I suppose, to have some idea where we could get New Canaan’s top-ranked pizza. But it would have been much more helpful to know in advance which bar mixes the best Manhattan. Yet, so far, nothing. If I hadn’t done my own prior field research, I wouldn’t have had a clue.
Now that I think of it, a New Canaan Board of Manhattan Tasters, modeled on the committee of dry cleaner judges committee I described before, would provide a valuable public service. I wonder where I can go to apply.

